The 1991 season was supposed to be a "rebuilding" year for the Boy’s Soccer team. Thanks to victories over strong programs such as PDS, Gill-St. Bernards and Tenafly, the team ended with an overall record of 17-3-2. However, it was the noise they made in the County Tournament that garnered all the attention they received. The boys brought home the school’s first ever Bergen County Championship. It was also the first time a small school won the tournament. Facing Tenafly in the championship, it took two games to determine a winner, as the first game ended in a 1-1 tie after overtime. In overtime of the replay, Derek Franks scored twice to put away the opposition. The game went on to be named “Game of the Century” by the Bergen Record. Derek Frank and Gregg Franco were named to the 1st Team All-County.